Differential Comparative Semantics #
@cite{schwarzschild-2005} @cite{solt-2015} @cite{winter-2005}
Compositional semantics for measure phrase differentials in comparatives: "3 inches taller", "twice as tall as".
Measure Phrase Composition #
@cite{schwarzschild-2005}: measure phrases modify the degree argument of the comparative, specifying the gap between matrix and standard degrees.
"A is 3 inches taller than B" iff height(A) - height(B) = 3 inches
This requires a ratio scale (with a meaningful zero point and unit), not just an ordinal or interval scale. Hence "3 inches taller" ✓ but "*3 units more beautiful" ✗.
Differential comparative: "A is d-much Adj-er than B" iff the difference μ(A) - μ(B) = d.
Requires a type with subtraction (ring-like structure), not just ordering. This is what makes measure phrase differentials more restrictive than bare comparatives.
Equations
- Semantics.Degree.Differential.differentialComparative μ a b diff = (μ a - μ b = diff)
Instances For
The differential is positive iff the comparative holds.
Measurement level: what kind of scale an adjective's degrees live on. Measure phrase differentials require at least interval scale; factor phrases require ratio scale.
- ordinal : MeasurementLevel
- interval : MeasurementLevel
- ratio : MeasurementLevel
Instances For
Equations
- One or more equations did not get rendered due to their size.
Instances For
Does this measurement level admit measure phrase differentials?
Equations
- Semantics.Degree.Differential.admitsMeasurePhrase Semantics.Degree.Differential.MeasurementLevel.ratio = true
- Semantics.Degree.Differential.admitsMeasurePhrase Semantics.Degree.Differential.MeasurementLevel.interval = true
- Semantics.Degree.Differential.admitsMeasurePhrase Semantics.Degree.Differential.MeasurementLevel.ordinal = false
Instances For
Does this measurement level admit factor phrases ("twice as tall")?
Equations
- Semantics.Degree.Differential.admitsFactorPhrase Semantics.Degree.Differential.MeasurementLevel.ratio = true
- Semantics.Degree.Differential.admitsFactorPhrase Semantics.Degree.Differential.MeasurementLevel.interval = false
- Semantics.Degree.Differential.admitsFactorPhrase Semantics.Degree.Differential.MeasurementLevel.ordinal = false
Instances For
Factor phrase equative: "A is n times as tall as B" iff μ(A) = n × μ(B). Requires ratio scale: a meaningful zero point.
Equations
- Semantics.Degree.Differential.factorEquative μ a b factor = (μ a = factor * μ b)